This patch makes it so we attempt to resolve a symbol as the
non-obsolete commits in a change id if all other resolutions
fail.
This addresses issue #15. I decided to not require any operator for
looking up by change id. I want to make it as easy as possible to use
change ids instead of commit ids to see how well it works to interact
mostly with change ids instead of commit ids (I'll try to test that by
using it myself).
I'd like to experiment with mostly using change ids instead of commit
ids on the CLI. Then it needs to be easy to refer to the non-obsolete
commits in a change, which means we probably don't want to require any
operators (i.e. a plain change id should resolve to the non-obsolete
commits in the change). This patch prepares for letting a change id
resolve to (possibly) many commits.
I had initially hoped that the type-safety provided by the separate
`FileRepoPath` and `DirRepoPath` types would help prevent bugs. I'm
not sure if it has prevented any bugs so far. It has turned out that
there are more cases than I had hoped where it's unknown whether a
path is for a directory or a file. One such example is for the path of
a conflict. Since it can be conflict between a directory and a file,
it doesn't make sense to use either. Instead we end up with quite a
bit of conversion between the types. I feel like they are not worth
the extra complexity. This patch therefore starts simplifying it by
replacing uses of `FileRepoPath` by `RepoPath`. `DirRepoPath` is a
little more complicated because its string form ends with a '/'. I'll
address that in separate patches.
I thought I had looked for this case and cleaned up all the places
when I made `Transaction::commit()` return a new `ReadonlyRepo`. I
must have forgotten to do that, because there we tons of places to
clean up left.
This commit rewites the divergence-resolution part of `evolve()` as an
iterator (though not implementing the `Iterator` trait). Iterators are
just much easier to work with: they can easily be stopped, and errors
are easy to propagate. This patch therefore lets us propagate errors
from writing to stdout (typically pipe errors).
I've wanted the API to look like this for a while. It seems like a
good API to me. It means that the caller won't have to reload the repo
after committing. The cost seems relatively small. It involves copying
potentially a lot of data in memory (at least the View object), but it
shouldn't involve reading from disk or any other processing. To reduce
the amount of data to copy, it may be worth switching to persistent
data types. I've also wanted to do that for the copying we do when
start a transaction.
I couldn't measure any slowdown caused by this change.
The git.git repo seems to have lots of merges from far back in the
history into newer history. That results in `jj log -r 'git_refs()'`
being completely useless because of the number of such edges. For
example, v2.31.0 has almost 600 edges going out of it and presumably
merging (forking) back into various different previous versions. Git,
unlike Mercurial, seems to remove an edge from the graph if the edge
can also be reached via a longer path. This commit makes it so we also
do that (i.e. the filtered graph is a transitive reduction of the
graph before filtering).
This slows down `jj log -r ,,v2.0.0 -T ""` by about 2%. That's still
small enough that it doesn't seem worth it to have a separate iterator
for contiguous ranges (which would be an option).
When rendering a non-contiguous subset of the commits, we want to
still show the connections between the commits in the graph, even
though they're not directly connected. This commit introduces an
adaptor for the revset iterators that also yield the edges to show in
such a simplified graph.
This has no measurable impact on `jj log -r ,,v2.0.0` in the git.git
repo.
The output of `jj log -r 'v1.0.0 | v2.0.0'` now looks like this:
```
o e156455ea491 e156455ea491 gitster@pobox.com 2014-05-28 11:04:19.000 -07:00 refs/tags/v2.0.0
:\ Git 2.0
: ~
o c2f3bf071ee9 c2f3bf071ee9 junkio@cox.net 2005-12-21 00:01:00.000 -08:00 refs/tags/v1.0.0
~ GIT 1.0.0
```
Before this commit, it looked like this:
```
o e156455ea491 e156455ea491 gitster@pobox.com 2014-05-28 11:04:19.000 -07:00 refs/tags/v2.0.0
| Git 2.0
| o c2f3bf071ee9 c2f3bf071ee9 junkio@cox.net 2005-12-21 00:01:00.000 -08:00 refs/tags/v1.0.0
| |\ GIT 1.0.0
```
The output of `jj log -r 'git_refs()'` in the git.git repo is still
completely useless (it's >350k lines and >500MB of data). I think
that's because we don't filter out edges to ancestors that we have
transitive edges to. Mercurial also doesn't filter out such edges, but
Git (with `--simplify-by-decoration`) seems to filter them out. I'll
change it soon so we filter them out.
This adds a `git_refs()` revset that includes all commits pointed to
by a git ref. It's not very useful yet because the graph log doesn't
use the right type of edges for non-contiguous commits.
This lets you use the same operator as we currently have for ancestors
and descendants (`,,`) to also specify a DAG range. That's what
Mercurial uses the `::` operator for and what Git has `git log
--ancestry-path` for.
I really liked the idea of having the operators for parents and
ancestors (etc.) look similar, but that turned out to be problematic
when we want to add an infix operator for a DAG range (hg's `::`
revset operator and git's `--ancestry-path` flag). Let's say we chose
`:*:` as the operator. Part of the problem is how to parse `foo:*:bar`
without eagerly parsing the `foo:`. It would also be nicer to use
exactly the same operator as prefix, postfix, and infix. Since the
"parents" operator can be repeated, we can't have it be just `:` and
the "ancestors" operator be `::`. We could make the "ancestors"
operator be something like `*:*` (or anything symmetric with the `:`
symbol on the inside). However, at that point, the operator is getting
ugly and hard to type. Another option would be to use `:` for
ancestors and `::` for parents, but that is counterintuitive and get
annoying if you want to repeat it. So it seems that the best option is
to simply pick different symbols for parents/children and
ancestors/descendants/range.
This patch changes the ancestors/descendants operators to both be
`,,`. I'm not at all attached to that particular symbol. I suspect
we'll change it later.
This adds `children(<set>)` and `<set>:` for the children of the given
set, and `descendants(<set>)` and `<set>:*` for the descendants of the
given set. The children and descendants are filtered to be among
ancestors of non-obsolete commits. I haven't added a way of overriding
that yet.
The tests don't need any complex set up (no repo necessary), so they
can be in the `revset` module itself. I'm sure we'll need to split up
that module later (at least separate out the parsing), but that's a
separate problem.
This change adds a `non_obsolete_heads(<set>)` revset, which walks up
ancestors of the input set until it gets to a non-obsolete and
non-pruned commit. That's what we do by default in `jj log`
(i.e. without `--all`). Now we can make `jj log` use revsets and teach
it a `-r` option!
This adds `parents(foo)` and `ancestors(foo)` as alternative ways of
writing `:foo` and `*:foo`.
I haven't added support for for whitespace yet; the parsing is very
strict. The error messages will also need to be improved later.
This patch adds initial support for a DSL for specifying revisions
inspired by Mercurial's "revset" language. The initial support
includes prefix operators ":" (parents) and "*:" (ancestors) with
naive parsing of the revsets. Mercurial uses postfix operator "^" for
parent 1 just like Git does. It uses prefix operator "::" for
ancestors and the same operator as postfix operator for descendants. I
did it differently because I like the idea of using the same operator
as prefix/postfix depending on desired direction, so I wanted to apply
that to parents/children as well (and for
predecessors/successors). The "*" in the "*:" operator is copied from
regular expression syntax. Let's see how it works out. This is an
experimental VCS, after all.
I've updated the CLI to use the new revset support.
The implementation feels a little messy, but you have to start
somewhere...
This actually seems to make it slightly slower, but it fixes an
important bug (we used to evolve only one topological branch per `jj
evolve` call). The slowdown seemed to be on the order of 5% when
evolving 100 commits on git.git's "what's cooking" branch.
I suspect that at least one reason that I didn't make
`MutableRepo::base_repo` by an `Arc<ReadonlyRepo>` before was that I
thought that that would mean that `start_transaction()` would need be
moved off of `ReadonlyRepo` so it can be given an
`&Arc<ReadonlyRepo>`, which would make it much less convenient to
use. It turns out that a `self` argument can actually be of type
`&Arc<ReadonlyRepo>`.
I just changed my `~/.gitignore` and some tests started failing
because the working copy respects the user's `~/.gitignore`. We should
probably not depend on `$HOME` in the library crate. For now, this
patch just makes sure we set it to an arbitrary directory in the tests
where it matters.
This patch continues the work from the previous pathc. From this
patch, we no longer calculate the evolution state just because a
transaction starts. We still unnecessarily calculate it when adding a
commit within the transaction, however. I'll fix that next.
It's sometimes useful to create a `RepoLoader` given an existing
`ReadonlyRepo`. We already do that in `ReadonlyRepo::reload()`. This
patch repurposes `ReadonlyRepo::reload()` for that.
This is yet another step towards making the `View` types
simpler. Perhaps we eventually won't need to wrap the types returned
from the `OpStore` at all.
It can be useful to write an operation to the `OpStore` without also
making it visible when you load the repo. I had planned to add that
functionality at least for hooks, so the hooks can be run commands
with `jj --at-op=<operation>` and decide whether to publish the
operation. However, the immediate goal is to let us rewrite
`op_heads_store::merge_op_heads()` to use the usual `Transaction`
API. That needs to be able to just write the operation without
publishing it, since the publishing step takes a long, which
`op_heads_store::merge_op_heads()` (its caller, actually) has already
taken.
I'd like to make `ReadonlyView` and `MutableView` focused on just the
state of the view (i.e. the set of heads, git refs, etc.). The
responsibility for managing the `.jj/view/op_heads/` directory should
be moved out of it. This prepares for that.
The only way to load the repo at a current operation (as with
`--at-op`) is currently to first load it at the head operation and
then call `reload()` on the repo. This patch makes it so we can load
the repo directly at the requested operation.
Evolution needs to have fast access to the predecessors. This change
adds that information to the commit index.
Evolution also needs fast access to the change id and the bit saying
whether a commit is pruned. We'll add those soon.
Some tests changed because they previously added commits with
predecessors that were not indexed, which is no longer allowed from
this change. (We'll probably eventually want to allow that again, so
that the user can prune predecessors they no longer care about from
the repo.)
We currently write a new incremental index file every time. That means
that the stack of index files quickly gets deep, which makes it slow
to read the index. This commit makes it so that we squash the new
index segment into its parent if the parent has fewer commits. That
means we'll limit the number of files to O(log n). Writes time will
also be O(log n) on average.
I've confused myself a few times already thinking that level 0 is the
root, so that's probably more intuitive. It also makes tests simpler
because the initial part of the list is unchanged when a new
transaction commits.
With this change, we start writing the incremental index to disk, so
the next reader won't have to re-read the commits and create the
index.
As of this change, we simply write a new index file for each
transaction. That will clearly mean that the stack of files gets deep
pretty quickly. For now, the user will have to do `jj debug reindex`
when things get slow. I plan to change it so instead of writing an
incremental index file every time, we first check if the new index
file would have at least as many commits as the parent file, and if it
will, we write a combined one instead. That should apply recursively,
so we'd have O(log n) index files.
The check for adding an existing commit to the index only checked if
the commit was already in the `MutableIndex`, not if it was already in
the parent `ReadonlyIndex`.
With tons of groundwork done, wee can now finally keep the index up to
date within a transaction! That means that we can start relying on the
index to always be valid, so we can use it e.g. for finding common
ancestors within a transaction. That should help speed up `jj evolve`
immensely on large repos.
We still don't write the updated index to disk when the transaction
closes. That will come later.
`Transaction::add_head()` currently invalidates the whole evolution
state. We've had support for incrementally updating evolution since
4619942a57. We should start taking advantage of that. Let's add a
fast-path in `Transaction::add_head()` for the common case where we
add a single commit on top of an existing head. That cheap an simple
to check for. However, it won't cover the case of adding a child off
of a non-head. It's still a good start.
I want to keep the index updated within the transaction. I tried doing
that by adding a `trait Index`, implemented by `ReadonlyIndex` and
`MutableIndex`. However, `ReadonlyRepo::index` is of type
`Mutex<Option<Arc<IndexFile>>>` (because it is lazily initialized),
and we cannot get a `&dyn Index` that lives long enough to be returned
from a `Repo::index()` from that. It seems the best solution is to
instead create an `Index` enum (instead of a trait), with one readonly
and one mutable variant. This commit starts the migration to that
design by replacing the `Repo` trait by an enum. I never intended for
there there to be more implementations of `Repo` than `ReadonlyRepo`
and `MutableRepo` anyway.
I've been confused twice that rebasing an open commit so it results in
conflicts doesn't show the conflicts in the log output. That's because
we create a successor instead if a commit with conflicts is open. I
guess I thought it would be expected that a child commit was not
created. Since it seems surprising in practice, let's change it and
we'll see if the new behavior is more or less surprising.
We want to be able to be able to do fast `.contains()` checks on the
result, so `Iterator` was a bad type. We probably should hide the
exact type (currently `HashSet` for both readonly and mutable views),
but we can do that later. I actually thought I'd want to use
`.contains()` for indiciting public-phase commits in the log output,
but of course want to also indicate ancestors as public. This still
seem like a step (mostly) in the right direction.
Mercurial's "phase" concept is important for evolution, and it's also
useful for filtering out uninteresting commits from log
output. Commits are typically marked "public" when they are pushed to
a remote. The CLI prevents public commits from being rewritten. Public
commits cannot be obsolete (even if they have a successor, they won't
be considered obsolete like non-public commits would).
This commits just makes space for tracking the public heads in the
View.
All commits in the view are supposed to be reachable from its
heads. If a head is removed and there are git refs pointing to
ancestors of it (or to the removed head itself), we should make that
ancestor a head.
I think it's better to let the caller decide if the parents should be
added. One use case for removing a head is when fetching from a Git
remote where a branch has been rewritten. In that case, it's probably
the best user experience to remove the old head. With the current
semantics of `View::remove_head()`, we would need to walk up the graph
to find a commit that's an ancestor and for each commit we remove as
head, its parents get temporarily added as heads. It's much easier for
callers that want to add the parents as heads to do that.
Git refs are important at least for understanding where the remote
branches are. This commit adds support for tracking them in the view
and makes `git::import_refs()` update them.
When merging views (either because of concurrent operations or when
undoing an earlier operation), there can be conflicts between git ref
changes. I ignored that for now and let the later operation win. That
will probably be good enough for a while. It's not hard to detect the
conflicts, but I haven't yet decided how to handle them. I'm leaning
towards representing the conflicting refs in the view just like how we
represent conflicting files in the tree.
This commits makes it so that running commands outside a repo results
in an error message instead of a panic.
We still don't look for a `.jj/` directory in ancestors of the current
directory.
I'm preparing to publish an early version before someone takes the
name(s) on crates.io. "jj" has been taken by a seemingly useless
project, but "jujube" and "jujube-lib" are still available, so let's
use those.
When you run e.g. `jj st` outside of a repo, it just
crashes. That'll probably give new users a bad impression, so I
was planning to improve error handling a bit. A good place to
start is by fixing the code I recently added (which obviously
should have been using `thiserror` from the beginning). That's
what this commit does.
Also, this is the first commit in this repo created with
Jujube! I've just started dogfooding it myself.
This adds `jj git fetch` for fetching from a git remote. There remote
has to be added in the underlying git repo if it doesn't already
exist. I think command will still be useful on typical small projects
with just a single remote on GitHub. With this and the `jj git push` I
added recently, I think I have enough for my most of my own
interaction with GitHub.
The fact that no commits from the underlying Git repo were imported
when creating a new Jujube repo from it was quite surprising. This
commit finally fixes that.
When using Git as a store, new commits created in the underlying Git
repo are only made visible by making changes on top of them (e.g by
checking them out, so a working copy commit is created on top). That's
especially confusing when creating a new repo backed by an existing
Git repo, because the commits from that repo don't show up.
This commit prepares for fixing that by adding a function for updating
heads based on git refs. Since we don't yet track git refs (or
anything similar), the function just makes sure the refs are visible
in the Jujube repo by making them (anonymous) heads.
`Transaction::add_head()` and others would let the caller add
non-heads to the set (i.e. ancestors of others heads) and the the
non-heads were filterd out when the transaction was committed. That's
a little surprising, so let's try to keep the set valid even within a
transaction. That will surely make commands that add many commits
noticeably slower in large repos. Hopefully we can improve that
later.
It's annoying to have to have the Git repo and Jujube repo in separate
directories. This commit adds `jj init --git`, which creates a new
Jujube repo with an empty, bare git repo in `.jj/git/`. Hopefully the
`jj git` subcommands will eventually provide enough functionality for
working with the Git repo that the user won't have to use Git commands
directly. If they still do, they can run them from inside `.jj/git/`,
or create a new worktree based on that bare repo.
The implementation is quite straight-forward. One thing to note is
that I made `.jj/store` support relative paths to the Git repo. That's
mostly so the Jujube repo can be moved around freely.
A pruned commit just indicates that its predecessors should be evolved
onto the pruned commit's parent instead of onto the pruned commit
itself. The pruned commit itself can be divergent. For example, if
there are several pruned sucessors of a commit, then it's unclear
where the predecessor's children should be rebased to.
Before this commit, when the `evolve()` evolved a stack of orphans, it
would use the evolve state from the beginning of the function to
calculate where they should go. That meant that only the bottom-most
orphan(s) would get evolved to their right place. This commit fixes
that by use the Transaction's evolution state.
The point of having the `modified` and `removed` files in the test was
to show that they don't get untracked, but I forgot to include them in
the `.gitignores`, so there was no reason they would have gotten
untracked anyway.
The project's source of truth is now in Git and I really miss support
for anonymous heads and evolution (compared to when the code was in
Mercurial). I'm therefore more motivated to make the tool useful for
day-to-day work on small repos, so I can use it myself. Until now, I
had been more focused on improving performance when it was used as a
read-only client for medium-to-large repos.
One important feature for my day-to-day work is support for
ignores. This commit adds simple and effective, but somewhat hacky
support for that. libgit2 requires a repo to check if a file should be
ignored (presumably so it can respect `.git/info/excludes`). To work
around that, we create a temporary git repo in `/tmp/` whenever the
working copy is committed. We set that temporary git repo's working
copy to be shared with our own working copy. Due to
https://github.com/libgit2/libgit2sharp/issues/1716 (which seems to
apply to the non-.NET version as well), this workaround unfortunately
leaves a .git file (pointing to the deleted temporary git repo) around
in every Jujube repo. That's always ignored by libgit2, so it's not
much of a problem.
This removes one level of indirection, which is nice because it was
visible to the callers. The `Index` struct is now empty. The next step
is obviously to delete it (and perhaps rename `IndexFile` to `Index`
or `ReadonlyIndex`).
